Shopping Cart
User Login 
Don’t Hire The First Good Candidate You Meet
Even with the evolution of technology, the hiring process is still daunting. From drafting all the materials to sifting through applicants, the process is time intensive. Since it is so easy for anyone to apply to a job now, companies are often overwhelmed with applicants from the very second they post an open job listing. Due to this high influx of candidates, hiring departments can easily get weary of managing it all. This can lead to jumping onto the first candidate they find that sort of meets the qualifications.
As someone with over twenty years of experience hiring candidates and helping job seekers optimize their application materials, I encourage companies to keep looking. Yes, the process can be fatiguing. Yes, it can be extremely overwhelming. However, hiring the first candidate you meet that seems okay can actually cost your company in the long run.
The Cost Of The Wrong Hire
First and foremost, hiring someone who is not completely qualified means that training will be involved. This can be expensive for a company, and it means that a person will not be able to work while they are learning something new — which also costs the company in productivity. There is always the risk as well that you hire someone, pour lots of resources into them to train them, and then they leave.
However, this training period does not just affect the new hire. It also affects other team members. There will most likely be a team member that is conducting the training or even just following up on a new hire’s progress. That is time that person could have spent doing other things for the company. Additionally, while the new person is training, what happens to the work that falls under their job description?
Companies often ask other team members to pick up the slack in the meantime. This causes others to be stressed, overloaded, and they might fall behind on the work they are supposed to be doing themselves — not just the extra they have been asked to take on. While teams are always excited to fill an open spot, onboarding someone new can be a little tricky.
What To Do About The Perfect Hire
It should be mentioned that you will almost never find your dream candidate. That unicorn you are looking for is just that: a nonexistent unicorn. While you should not just hire the first person you meet that seems to somewhat fit the requirements, you also should not hold out for an absolutely perfect hire.
Instead, find a candidate who gets close to all the requirements. For example, your team uses Jira to manage projects, and you are looking to hire a new project manager. This new hire might not have experience in Jira, but maybe they have experience in Asana. While the two systems have their differences, they are extremely similar. That candidate has a good foundation in project management software that can be translated to a new one. On the other hand, if there is a candidate that has zero experience in any type of project management software, you should probably look for someone else.
Look for someone who is a quick learner that can make up for any experience they might be lacking, and consider slowly onboarding a team member. For example, if you are hiring someone to create marketing emails, start them off creating emails, but wait to train them on the project management software they have to use to keep track of said emails. This will ensure that their immediate duties are taken over so the rest of the team is not stressed as they continue to try and create emails plus do everything else.
Tips To Overcome Hiring Fatigue
If your company has been searching for a candidate for a bit and you are feeling fatigued, it is important to take breaks. Again, the wrong candidate can be extremely costly for your company. If something goes wrong with a new hire and they leave, the entire process must be repeated for someone else.
If your team feels fatigued from looking through all the applicants, have them take a break. This might look like just getting up to get some coffee or trading some tasks with a team member so that they can do something else for a bit to clear their mind.
Offer them encouragement. The right team member is just around the corner, they just have to keep searching. Bonuses are also a great incentive to encourage employees, so during extra tricky hiring times, you can offer a bonus for bringing in quality candidates.
Bring in AI to help the process. If your company is not already using AI, consider doing so now. The software can easily read through hundreds or thousands of resumes in an instant, pulling out qualified candidates by reviewing keywords they have used in their resume and comparing the work history/education to the job requirements. AI can be a huge help here as the first stage of the hiring process — reviewing potential applicant’s materials — is often the longest.
However, if your company prefers to do things the old-fashioned way, try to batch potential candidates. This means that you post the job. Leave it open until it hits a certain number of applicants. Maybe your team can handle fifty or maybe they can only handle ten. Whichever works best for your team, wait until you receive that many applicants and then turn off the job listing. That way your team does not feel overwhelmed looking at current applicants while new ones pile up. Then, if quality candidates are not found in that original pool, you can open up the job listing again.
Just remember, while hiring a new team member to help the company is important, your current employees are just as important. Make sure you are listening to them on how they feel about the process to avoid hiring burnout.
